The President of BCCI - N Srinivasan, more importantly, the owner of CSK!
Selection Committee Chairman - K Srikkanth, mentor (possibly part owner) of CSK
Indian Team Captain - Mahendra Singh Dhoni, more importantly CSK captain!!
The trio have presided over the demise of Indian cricket in England and recently in Australia. Neither the losses nor the manner of the losses seem to bring any emotion out of these Maharajahs! Reaction - "come to India, we will show you" - childish emotions.
In sharp contrast, even the smallest problem to affect the CSK brings out raw emotions and immediate repercussions! Irfan Pathan crossed Dhoni in IPL 3 by taking his wicket in a critical last over and celebrated a rare win for the Punjab team! You should have seen Dhoni's irritated and wild look at Irfan! Even the two back to back 0-4 losses against England and Australia have failed to bring any emotion out of Dhoni!!
Poor Irfan, he has paid a big price and hasn't found a place in the Indian team under Dhoni since. He has not merited a place even in the swinging and pacy wickets in Australia. Harbhajan Singh acted in an Ad and had a fallout with Dhoni over the "Have I made it Large Ad". End result - Harbhajan has lost his place in the team. Sehwag and Dhoni have had a recent fallout - result Sehwag was dropped for the MCG ODI!
Ravindra Jadeja, Ravi Ashwin, Suresh Raina - CSK players!! The list goes on. It doesn't matter that Jadeja played miserably in the first T20. He gets a second chance!! He plays miserably in the MCG ODI- end result he gets the nod again at Perth.
The list goes on..It is pretty clear that if you are connected to the CSK, your place in the Indian team is secure. It does not matter if the pitch supports spin or pace and the kind of player you are. Being an important pawn in the CSK equation is your ticket to permanency in the Indian team! Individual player performance are secondary.
In my opinion, CSK politics have destroyed the fabric of Indian cricket! The day IPL becomes bigger than the national cricket spells the end of Indian cricket. Kudos to Sahara for taking a stand! Hope they stick to their position and bring BCCI and N Srinivasan to their knees. Now one hears of how the Auctions were rigged (Flintoff). One wonders what else in Indian cricket is rigged.
I like the IPL and have been a passionate supporter of CSK for 4 years. I even attended the inaugural CSK match in IPL1. But I value my National team more than anything else. I personally will not be supporting CSK any more!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
P.S. I have been an avid Dhoni fan for many years enjoying the T20 World Cup win, the recent World Cup win and the many successes for CSK and also a Krish Srikkanth fan for as long as I can remember - I even visited his house in Chennai once with my cousin Dinesh and have an autographed photograph in the first page of my album!
Showing posts with label Sai Posts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sai Posts. Show all posts
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Friday, January 27, 2012
End of Era! Goodbye Laxman, Dravid....
Goodbye Dravid, Laxman, Tendulkar and Zaheer Khan! (Zaheer at 37 will not be part of the visiting Indian team to Australia in 3-4 years time). You will not be seen in Tests in Australia again!
Dravid and Laxman have definitely played their last game for India. It should never have ended like this. Great careers need a better ending! These illustrious batsmen and cricketers have played excellent innings and won games and series for India and held Indian cricket high for a decade.It is very sad that they will be remembered for losing their last 8 Test Matches and more importantly being white washed 0-4 in their last 2 Test series!
Unfortunately they probably have themselves to blame for the situation they are in. In my opinion, they should have announced their retirements coming in to the series and one or two of them should have hung up their boots after Sydney! That way they could have left with a little bit of pride and dignity.
The selectors cannot but escape blame for some of what has happened. If one or two of the senior players had been dropped and a youngster or two given a chance, India might not have seen this exodus. I personally believe there is likelihood that Tendulkar will score his 100th century (for whatever it is worth!) in the One Day series and announce his retirement from Tests. The entire middle order will then be wiped out in one go! I have been saying this from Day 1 but I will repeat the question - Why were Irfan Pathan and Bhajji not picked for this tour - remember horses for courses?
Dhoni is also culpable for playing the same batting line up, in the same batting order, for 8 innings and hoping for a better result. People talk of the miracle at Calcutta. That was a great achievement but it also involved some inspired captaincy in letting the top scorer of the first innings, Laxman come in at No 3 in the second innings. India's last victory at Perth saw Irfan Pathan opening the batting, another inspired move from an inspiring captain. One saw nothing of that sort in either England or in Australia.
Dhoni clearly does not understand tests and what is needed to win them, especially overseas. Saha has proved to be a better batsman and keeper and Dhoni should gracefully take responsibility and retire from Tests! He is a very good limited overs player and captain and should continue to be so!
Duncan Fletcher, the highly paid, non inspiring coach should be immediately dropped along with his coterie of batting, bowling and feilding coach. India needs a strong, inspiring coach, someone like Kumble, Ganguly or Ravi Shastri!
Anyways thank you Laxman, Dravid and Tendulkar. It was good while it lasted. Good luck and Good bless!!!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Dravid and Laxman have definitely played their last game for India. It should never have ended like this. Great careers need a better ending! These illustrious batsmen and cricketers have played excellent innings and won games and series for India and held Indian cricket high for a decade.It is very sad that they will be remembered for losing their last 8 Test Matches and more importantly being white washed 0-4 in their last 2 Test series!
Unfortunately they probably have themselves to blame for the situation they are in. In my opinion, they should have announced their retirements coming in to the series and one or two of them should have hung up their boots after Sydney! That way they could have left with a little bit of pride and dignity.
The selectors cannot but escape blame for some of what has happened. If one or two of the senior players had been dropped and a youngster or two given a chance, India might not have seen this exodus. I personally believe there is likelihood that Tendulkar will score his 100th century (for whatever it is worth!) in the One Day series and announce his retirement from Tests. The entire middle order will then be wiped out in one go! I have been saying this from Day 1 but I will repeat the question - Why were Irfan Pathan and Bhajji not picked for this tour - remember horses for courses?
Dhoni is also culpable for playing the same batting line up, in the same batting order, for 8 innings and hoping for a better result. People talk of the miracle at Calcutta. That was a great achievement but it also involved some inspired captaincy in letting the top scorer of the first innings, Laxman come in at No 3 in the second innings. India's last victory at Perth saw Irfan Pathan opening the batting, another inspired move from an inspiring captain. One saw nothing of that sort in either England or in Australia.
Dhoni clearly does not understand tests and what is needed to win them, especially overseas. Saha has proved to be a better batsman and keeper and Dhoni should gracefully take responsibility and retire from Tests! He is a very good limited overs player and captain and should continue to be so!
Duncan Fletcher, the highly paid, non inspiring coach should be immediately dropped along with his coterie of batting, bowling and feilding coach. India needs a strong, inspiring coach, someone like Kumble, Ganguly or Ravi Shastri!
Anyways thank you Laxman, Dravid and Tendulkar. It was good while it lasted. Good luck and Good bless!!!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Sunday, January 8, 2012
How can India salvage this series?
Indeed how is this possible? This is the question in the minds of every Indian fan! In my opinion, there are two aspects, one mental and one cricketing.
Lets look at the cricketing part - One wonders why Indians are so good at home and so bad overseas. First and foremost to win a Test match, you need to take 20 wickets within 200 overs or so. Simple as that. In the sub-continent conditions, India can go in with 2 spinners and 2 pacemen. The 2 spinners can bowl long spells and take wickets as well. Overseas, India goes in with three pacemen and one spinner. In my opinion, it is too much to ask of the pacemen to bowl 50 overs each a game with intensity and also take on average 5 wickets a game! If one bowler has a bad day, then the load of bowling and wicket taking has to be shared by two pacemen - the spinner not being effective till late in the 4th day (most maches finish by then).
My mantra is simple - India needs to go in with 5 bowlers - 4 pacemen and 1 spinner. This is our best chance of taking 20 wickets within 200 overs. The last game we won in Australia, Perth 2008 saw 5 bowlers in the Indian team with Irfan Pathan opening. I would like to see an SOS go to Irfan. But that is not going to happen. The only viable option then is to replace Kohli with a paceman for Perth. We have seen that Ravi Ashwin and Zak are good enough batsmen. The management is blaming the batting and the batsmen need to take more responsibility but that alone will not win us games.
The next change is to the batting order. Dhoni needs to move up to number 3. He is best when he is attacking and under no pressure. At No. 3, he can bat freely and play his natural attacking game with Dravid, Tendulkar and Laxman or Rohit Sharma or Gambhir to follow. Rohit Sharma needs to be brought in instead of Gambhir or Laxman and asked to open the batting. Gambhir, if he is in the team, can go down to No 6.
Dhoni's captaincy needs to change, failing which he needs to be replaced as captain. Although the margins of defeat were big, I believe the 2 games were lost due to a few blunders at critical stages. At the MCG, India lost because Dhoni failed to attack late on the 3rd day and let the game drift. Else India could have bundled Australia out and kept the target to under 200. At the SCG, the best chance for India was to take a wicket early on the second day, or atleast just before the new ball was due. This would have put pressure on the brittle Aussie middle order and might have triggered a collapse (There are a number of precedents for this in 2011). Instead Dhoni bowled part timers with a defensive field and ensured that the Aussies had well-set batsmen to face the new ball. In stark contrast, Michael Clarke attacked Tendulkar and Laxman just before the new ball was due on the 4th day and triggered a collapse. The rest, as they say, is history.
Now lets look at the mental part - First and foremost, the players need to believe that they can pull it off. There is no substitute for this. Some of the young players were seen late at night at night clubs two nights before the MCG game and also again on Friday night after losing the SCG game. This is simply not acceptable. Dhoni and the team management need to put a curb to this and ensure that the entire focus is on the cricket and on winning. The players need to want to win, at least as much as us fans want them to win!!!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Lets look at the cricketing part - One wonders why Indians are so good at home and so bad overseas. First and foremost to win a Test match, you need to take 20 wickets within 200 overs or so. Simple as that. In the sub-continent conditions, India can go in with 2 spinners and 2 pacemen. The 2 spinners can bowl long spells and take wickets as well. Overseas, India goes in with three pacemen and one spinner. In my opinion, it is too much to ask of the pacemen to bowl 50 overs each a game with intensity and also take on average 5 wickets a game! If one bowler has a bad day, then the load of bowling and wicket taking has to be shared by two pacemen - the spinner not being effective till late in the 4th day (most maches finish by then).
My mantra is simple - India needs to go in with 5 bowlers - 4 pacemen and 1 spinner. This is our best chance of taking 20 wickets within 200 overs. The last game we won in Australia, Perth 2008 saw 5 bowlers in the Indian team with Irfan Pathan opening. I would like to see an SOS go to Irfan. But that is not going to happen. The only viable option then is to replace Kohli with a paceman for Perth. We have seen that Ravi Ashwin and Zak are good enough batsmen. The management is blaming the batting and the batsmen need to take more responsibility but that alone will not win us games.
The next change is to the batting order. Dhoni needs to move up to number 3. He is best when he is attacking and under no pressure. At No. 3, he can bat freely and play his natural attacking game with Dravid, Tendulkar and Laxman or Rohit Sharma or Gambhir to follow. Rohit Sharma needs to be brought in instead of Gambhir or Laxman and asked to open the batting. Gambhir, if he is in the team, can go down to No 6.
Dhoni's captaincy needs to change, failing which he needs to be replaced as captain. Although the margins of defeat were big, I believe the 2 games were lost due to a few blunders at critical stages. At the MCG, India lost because Dhoni failed to attack late on the 3rd day and let the game drift. Else India could have bundled Australia out and kept the target to under 200. At the SCG, the best chance for India was to take a wicket early on the second day, or atleast just before the new ball was due. This would have put pressure on the brittle Aussie middle order and might have triggered a collapse (There are a number of precedents for this in 2011). Instead Dhoni bowled part timers with a defensive field and ensured that the Aussies had well-set batsmen to face the new ball. In stark contrast, Michael Clarke attacked Tendulkar and Laxman just before the new ball was due on the 4th day and triggered a collapse. The rest, as they say, is history.
Now lets look at the mental part - First and foremost, the players need to believe that they can pull it off. There is no substitute for this. Some of the young players were seen late at night at night clubs two nights before the MCG game and also again on Friday night after losing the SCG game. This is simply not acceptable. Dhoni and the team management need to put a curb to this and ensure that the entire focus is on the cricket and on winning. The players need to want to win, at least as much as us fans want them to win!!!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
Black Day for Indian Cricket - SCG Day 2
What an abysmal performance by the Indian cricket team at the SCG! After an indifferent batting performance, India went into Day 2 with a more than even chance of winning the game. At the end of the day, there is only one team that can win this game. It was an abject surrender by the captain and the bowlers. Don't forget, the Aussies went into the 3rd day of the MCG Test in a similar situation and managed to get the last 7 Indian wickets on the third morning for next to nothing.
Zaheer Khan came into his spell wishing he was somewhere else. Although Ishant and Umesh bowled a few good balls, there were always one or two bad balls in every over. All the batsmen had to do was to wait for the gift. Dhoni's field setting was abysmal - one was left to wonder whether he was attacking or defending. After scoring 191, India had only one option and that was to attack! They needed to look for a wicket every ball and try and restrict the lead.
Instead one saw extended spells from part time bowlers - Sehwag and Kohli, that too with a defensive field. If Dhoni was trying to break the partnership, I wonder how. Ravi Ashwin, India's strike spinner did not merit an attacking field. The entire Indian mindset was to let the Aussie batsmen make a mistake and then we will see. India needed one or two wickets in the first hour or atleast in the first session to make a mtach of it. This, on a pitch that produced 13 wickets on day 1 and against two under pressure batsmen. This Aussie team has a history of batting collapses in the recent past and all it needed was a trigger. The Indians were found wanting! Our strike bowler could not even hit the stumps with his bowling arm to run out Ponting on 99 and our second strike bowler could not hold on to a catch of his own bowling!!
I for one aleast expected a 5 to 10 over attacking spell from the frontline bowlers prior to the second new ball so the Indans could get new batsmen. Instead we had an extended spell from the part-time bowlers. This bordered on ridiculous. And then it was back to the part timers once the second new ball barely was 20 overs old. Are the Indians now playing for the 3rd new ball? More likely, Dhoni is waiting for the Aussie declaration.
Full credit to Ricky Ponting, Michael Clarke and Michael Hussey for delivering a fantastic batting performance under pressure. This shows the difference between a great team and a good team, and the difference between match winners and batting geniuses and the differnece between a team that wants to win and a group of players who hanker for personal glory.
The Indians keep going back to Eden Gardens 2001, but guys this was 10 years ago in a home ground and the Aussie lead was 271. The lead is already 291 today with 6 wickets in hand with the Indians not even trying to get the wickets. More likely than not, the ball will start doing something once the Indians get to bat later today and we will see an abject surrender and an innngs defeat by the end of today's play. I hope I am proved wrong and am forced to eat my words but that is not going to happen!
Zaheer Khan came into his spell wishing he was somewhere else. Although Ishant and Umesh bowled a few good balls, there were always one or two bad balls in every over. All the batsmen had to do was to wait for the gift. Dhoni's field setting was abysmal - one was left to wonder whether he was attacking or defending. After scoring 191, India had only one option and that was to attack! They needed to look for a wicket every ball and try and restrict the lead.
Instead one saw extended spells from part time bowlers - Sehwag and Kohli, that too with a defensive field. If Dhoni was trying to break the partnership, I wonder how. Ravi Ashwin, India's strike spinner did not merit an attacking field. The entire Indian mindset was to let the Aussie batsmen make a mistake and then we will see. India needed one or two wickets in the first hour or atleast in the first session to make a mtach of it. This, on a pitch that produced 13 wickets on day 1 and against two under pressure batsmen. This Aussie team has a history of batting collapses in the recent past and all it needed was a trigger. The Indians were found wanting! Our strike bowler could not even hit the stumps with his bowling arm to run out Ponting on 99 and our second strike bowler could not hold on to a catch of his own bowling!!
I for one aleast expected a 5 to 10 over attacking spell from the frontline bowlers prior to the second new ball so the Indans could get new batsmen. Instead we had an extended spell from the part-time bowlers. This bordered on ridiculous. And then it was back to the part timers once the second new ball barely was 20 overs old. Are the Indians now playing for the 3rd new ball? More likely, Dhoni is waiting for the Aussie declaration.
Full credit to Ricky Ponting, Michael Clarke and Michael Hussey for delivering a fantastic batting performance under pressure. This shows the difference between a great team and a good team, and the difference between match winners and batting geniuses and the differnece between a team that wants to win and a group of players who hanker for personal glory.
The Indians keep going back to Eden Gardens 2001, but guys this was 10 years ago in a home ground and the Aussie lead was 271. The lead is already 291 today with 6 wickets in hand with the Indians not even trying to get the wickets. More likely than not, the ball will start doing something once the Indians get to bat later today and we will see an abject surrender and an innngs defeat by the end of today's play. I hope I am proved wrong and am forced to eat my words but that is not going to happen!
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
Sydney Test 2011 - Day 1
What a fantastic day for Test Cricket. An absolutely topsy turvy day where 13 wickets fell for the first time ever on Day 1 at an SCG Test. Just as I reached the stadium, Dhoni went out for a toss and won it. It was a crucial toss in the context of the Test and the series.
Even before we settled down into our seats, Gambhir was out for a 3rd ball duck. And then began a steady procession of Indian wickets - India consistently lost 2 wickets per hour throughout the day. Sachin got to 41 and was looking good for a half century if not a century when he got out 3 balls before the drink interval. Dhoni finally played a decent knock and it appeared that he and Ashwin would get past an hour without losing any wicket when Ashwin and Zak fell to consecutive balls, just before tea.
One must give credit to the Aussi bowlers - all 3 of them bowled to a consistent line and length and hardly bowled a bad ball. Kohli fell to ripper of a ball. VVS Laxman is not looking very very special any more with knocks of 2,1 and 2 in the last 3 innings. Dhoni managed to bat with the tail for the first time in a few innings, scoring a half century and getting India close to the respectable score of 200.
Zaheer Khan started with a bang and at 37 for 3, 191 looked like a respectable score and some of the Indians were even thinking of a 1st innings lead. But the wayward bowling of the rest of the bowlers and some sensible batting by Ponting and Clarke ensured that the Aussies finished the day ahead of India. 114 for 3 is a very good platform for Australia to build a massive lead and bat India out of the game.
All is not lost to India. At 24 overs, the ball is relatively new and the morning conditions on Day 2 will help the fast bowlers. Dhoni (and for that matter the bowlers themselves) need to back the bowlers and get an early breakthrough on Day 2. This will open up Hussey and Haddin, who are not in he best of form and the tail. If the bowlers can rip though the Aussie line up and restrict them to 200-225, India is in with a real chance. Laxman, Gambhir and Kohli who will all play for their spots, can rise to the occasion and set the Aussies a target of 200+ in the 4th innings, which might just prove too much for the brittle Aussie line-up.
But if India don't take an early wicket, we can sit back and watch Ponting and Clarke score match winning centuries and bat India out of the game and the series! There seems to be something about me going to the cricket and watching Ponting score a century! On a personal note, I will then need to wait for another 4 years to hope for a first ever series victory for India in Australia! I am off to the game tomorrow again and am hoping to see Sehwag and Tendulkar bat again and not watch Ponting and Clarke score centuries. Time will tell!
Even before we settled down into our seats, Gambhir was out for a 3rd ball duck. And then began a steady procession of Indian wickets - India consistently lost 2 wickets per hour throughout the day. Sachin got to 41 and was looking good for a half century if not a century when he got out 3 balls before the drink interval. Dhoni finally played a decent knock and it appeared that he and Ashwin would get past an hour without losing any wicket when Ashwin and Zak fell to consecutive balls, just before tea.
One must give credit to the Aussi bowlers - all 3 of them bowled to a consistent line and length and hardly bowled a bad ball. Kohli fell to ripper of a ball. VVS Laxman is not looking very very special any more with knocks of 2,1 and 2 in the last 3 innings. Dhoni managed to bat with the tail for the first time in a few innings, scoring a half century and getting India close to the respectable score of 200.
Zaheer Khan started with a bang and at 37 for 3, 191 looked like a respectable score and some of the Indians were even thinking of a 1st innings lead. But the wayward bowling of the rest of the bowlers and some sensible batting by Ponting and Clarke ensured that the Aussies finished the day ahead of India. 114 for 3 is a very good platform for Australia to build a massive lead and bat India out of the game.
All is not lost to India. At 24 overs, the ball is relatively new and the morning conditions on Day 2 will help the fast bowlers. Dhoni (and for that matter the bowlers themselves) need to back the bowlers and get an early breakthrough on Day 2. This will open up Hussey and Haddin, who are not in he best of form and the tail. If the bowlers can rip though the Aussie line up and restrict them to 200-225, India is in with a real chance. Laxman, Gambhir and Kohli who will all play for their spots, can rise to the occasion and set the Aussies a target of 200+ in the 4th innings, which might just prove too much for the brittle Aussie line-up.
But if India don't take an early wicket, we can sit back and watch Ponting and Clarke score match winning centuries and bat India out of the game and the series! There seems to be something about me going to the cricket and watching Ponting score a century! On a personal note, I will then need to wait for another 4 years to hope for a first ever series victory for India in Australia! I am off to the game tomorrow again and am hoping to see Sehwag and Tendulkar bat again and not watch Ponting and Clarke score centuries. Time will tell!
Sunday, January 1, 2012
SCG Test - A Preview
As I am preparing myself to go the hallowed SCG Ground tomorrow, I can't but think that this is a make or break Test for India. Despite holding the No 1 position in Tests for more than a year, India's record way from home is dismal. Just have a look at the record in 2011. After taking the advantage in England's first innings, India still managed to lose the series 4-0.
India's inability to remove the tail after scuttling through the top order seems to have become a habit. If you have a close look at the MCG Test, India lost the match in just 2 session, the final session of the 3rd Day and the first session of the 4th day. According to me, Dhoni and the team management made a conscious and strategic decision to let the Aussies bat through till early on the 4th Day. The reasoning behind this could have been that the Indians wanted to avoid batting during the difficult sessions. They probably wanted to restrict the Aussies to 240-250 and start batting after the first hour of th 4th batting. This strategy might hold merit, but it portrays a defensive and negative attitude. Also, the strategy backfired and the Aussie tail got 50 runs too many.
If India are to have any chance of having a better winning record overseas, regain their No 1 position and win their first ever Test Series in Australia, Dhoni and co need to throw away their negative attitude. When you are ahead, you need to press the advantage and attack every player including the tail. India have given away the initiative to Australia by letting the fledgling Aussie bowlng attack taste first blood and by allowing Pontng and Hussey to regain form. But all is not lost. More often than not Test Series are won and lost in the mind rather than on the field. The Indians need to back themselves to win the series. There is a precedence for this in 1992-93 when the West Indies went on to win the series 2-1 after losing the first test at MCG!
India are yet to win a Test Series in Australia and, in my 9 years in Australia, I am yet to go to a game which India has won! Both these records to need to be broken! Here's hoping that Sachin scores his 100th century at the 100th Test match at the SCG and India goes on to win the Test Match and the series!!! Jeetega bhai jeetaga, India jeetega! Aaj nahin to kal, kabhi to jeetega!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
India's inability to remove the tail after scuttling through the top order seems to have become a habit. If you have a close look at the MCG Test, India lost the match in just 2 session, the final session of the 3rd Day and the first session of the 4th day. According to me, Dhoni and the team management made a conscious and strategic decision to let the Aussies bat through till early on the 4th Day. The reasoning behind this could have been that the Indians wanted to avoid batting during the difficult sessions. They probably wanted to restrict the Aussies to 240-250 and start batting after the first hour of th 4th batting. This strategy might hold merit, but it portrays a defensive and negative attitude. Also, the strategy backfired and the Aussie tail got 50 runs too many.
If India are to have any chance of having a better winning record overseas, regain their No 1 position and win their first ever Test Series in Australia, Dhoni and co need to throw away their negative attitude. When you are ahead, you need to press the advantage and attack every player including the tail. India have given away the initiative to Australia by letting the fledgling Aussie bowlng attack taste first blood and by allowing Pontng and Hussey to regain form. But all is not lost. More often than not Test Series are won and lost in the mind rather than on the field. The Indians need to back themselves to win the series. There is a precedence for this in 1992-93 when the West Indies went on to win the series 2-1 after losing the first test at MCG!
India are yet to win a Test Series in Australia and, in my 9 years in Australia, I am yet to go to a game which India has won! Both these records to need to be broken! Here's hoping that Sachin scores his 100th century at the 100th Test match at the SCG and India goes on to win the Test Match and the series!!! Jeetega bhai jeetaga, India jeetega! Aaj nahin to kal, kabhi to jeetega!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Tuesday, December 27, 2011
Cricket commentary - Aussie style
Listening to some of the Aussie commentators on Channel 9, one would think that Rahul Dravid was legitimately out and that Technology had been used to reverse a legitimate decision! Mate, Siddle bowled a No Ball and did not deserve a wicket of the ball, get that? I know we all love winning and some like to win at any cost, but this is stretching the limit. A No Ball is a No Ball. Full stop! Always was, always will be. You can't take a wicket off a No Ball, simple as that!
I strongly support the DRS and believe that BCCI has made a mistake by not opting for it and may still pay a heavy price over this. When technology is available, umpiring errors should not allowed to determine the fate of the players and the match. Remember Ponting not given out at 97 at MCG 2003 and Symonds at SCG 2008 and Hussey being given out on Day 1, MCG 2011?
The argument is that because BCCI refused the use of DRS, India should not get the benefit of no-ball line calls. Guys this is the umpire's discretion and was used to check when Haddin was out as well. What next, no 3rd umpire calls for run outs? Will a win caused by taking wickets off no-balls and non-existent run outs cause joy? (Also please remember that the players still need to select to use DRS and by all counts Ed Cowan would have not asked for DRS as Haddin thought he was out.)
A section of the Australian media is behaving like my six year old who has been denied a lolly. Yes, the BCCI refused the use of DRS, but the ICC ruling is that both teams need to agree. If the ACB has a problem with this, it needs to be raised with the BCCI and the ICC. If the BCCI has more clout at the ICC than the ACB, this needs to be dealt with. Don't forget, not long ago, the ICC was ruled by the ECB and the ACB. I so miss the sane voice of Peter Roebuck!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
I strongly support the DRS and believe that BCCI has made a mistake by not opting for it and may still pay a heavy price over this. When technology is available, umpiring errors should not allowed to determine the fate of the players and the match. Remember Ponting not given out at 97 at MCG 2003 and Symonds at SCG 2008 and Hussey being given out on Day 1, MCG 2011?
The argument is that because BCCI refused the use of DRS, India should not get the benefit of no-ball line calls. Guys this is the umpire's discretion and was used to check when Haddin was out as well. What next, no 3rd umpire calls for run outs? Will a win caused by taking wickets off no-balls and non-existent run outs cause joy? (Also please remember that the players still need to select to use DRS and by all counts Ed Cowan would have not asked for DRS as Haddin thought he was out.)
A section of the Australian media is behaving like my six year old who has been denied a lolly. Yes, the BCCI refused the use of DRS, but the ICC ruling is that both teams need to agree. If the ACB has a problem with this, it needs to be raised with the BCCI and the ICC. If the BCCI has more clout at the ICC than the ACB, this needs to be dealt with. Don't forget, not long ago, the ICC was ruled by the ECB and the ACB. I so miss the sane voice of Peter Roebuck!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Monday, December 26, 2011
The curious case of the BCCI and the DRS
I for one can't fathom why the BCCI steadfastly refuses to embrace the DRS! There were three decisions yesterday that would have been overturned by DRS. A debutant would not have felt cheated out of a well-deserved hundred and a valiant veteran cheated out of a career. By the same token, India would be further into the Aussie tail. Incorrect umpire decisions must not be allowed to alter the course of a game and the career of cricketers. As a spectator, it leaves a bitter taste in the mouth.
It does not matter who has the overall gain. The situation could change today and a few more decisions could go against the Indians. What matters is that the umpires are human and there is technology available to the players to dispute decisions when they feel wronged! Hot spot, snicko meter and ball trajectory are based on science and offer both teams equal opportunities to question the umpires decision. The technology may not be a 100% accurate but it is better than relying solely on the umpire. I am sure the umpires feel less pressure when there is DRS available.
I was at the MCG in 2003 when Ponting clearly nicked one on 97 and went on to score 257 and who can forget the 2008 SCG Test where Symonds clearly nicked one and went on to score a century. DRS gives both teams an opportunity to ensure that such blatant errors are not allowed to change the course of a Test and a series. The argument that umpiring mistakes are part and parcel of the game and they even out in the long run, do not hold water. These views might have had limited value in the past but are no longer valid in light of technology. Sports need to embrace technology to keep up with the times and to entice spectators.
BCCI has a history of not embracing new trends - remember BCCI's steadfast opposition to T20! they even allowed an alternate league to flourish before the embraced the T20 spectacle. Will it take Sachin Tendulkar to be wrongly given out on 99 for BCCI to change its stance on DRS?
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
It does not matter who has the overall gain. The situation could change today and a few more decisions could go against the Indians. What matters is that the umpires are human and there is technology available to the players to dispute decisions when they feel wronged! Hot spot, snicko meter and ball trajectory are based on science and offer both teams equal opportunities to question the umpires decision. The technology may not be a 100% accurate but it is better than relying solely on the umpire. I am sure the umpires feel less pressure when there is DRS available.
I was at the MCG in 2003 when Ponting clearly nicked one on 97 and went on to score 257 and who can forget the 2008 SCG Test where Symonds clearly nicked one and went on to score a century. DRS gives both teams an opportunity to ensure that such blatant errors are not allowed to change the course of a Test and a series. The argument that umpiring mistakes are part and parcel of the game and they even out in the long run, do not hold water. These views might have had limited value in the past but are no longer valid in light of technology. Sports need to embrace technology to keep up with the times and to entice spectators.
BCCI has a history of not embracing new trends - remember BCCI's steadfast opposition to T20! they even allowed an alternate league to flourish before the embraced the T20 spectacle. Will it take Sachin Tendulkar to be wrongly given out on 99 for BCCI to change its stance on DRS?
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Labels:
Cricket General,
DRS,
India's Tour of Australia 2011-12,
MCG,
Sai Posts,
Tendulkar,
Test
Sunday, December 25, 2011
Boxing Day Test, MCG 2011 preview
As I am sitting in Sydney, in front of my TV, waiting for the Boxing Day Test to begin, I can't but miss Peter Roebuck's article in the Sydney Morning Herald. For the last 9 summers, I have read every single Peter Roebuck article and more often than not agreed with him. Here is my attempt to write an article in a similar vein.
The title would read "The late of two mis-selections". Lets start with Australia. The selection of Ricky Ponting and the omissions of Simon Katich and Usman Khwaja defy logic. Ricky Ponting is long past his due by date and should have gracefully retired. That the selectors led by Inverarity have lacked the courage to tap Ponting on his shoulder may come back to haunt the Aussies. He is a sitting duck and I for one won't be surprised if he his Ishant's bunny through this series! Usman Khwaja has shown great technique and deserved to be persisted with. If experience and form is a factor, Simon Katich (based on his average over the last 2 years) should have been an automatic selection! If Australia loses this game, Inverarity and his team have a lot to answer.
A look at the Indian bowling and one is surprised at the Indian selectors selecting a half fit Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma in the same team. Both have them have shown a penchant for falling apart during critical games. God forbid both of them break down during this critical Boxing Day test, and India will be left playing this game with no new ball bowlers. This will lead to Ponting and Hussey coming back to form! If India wanted to play both, it would have been logical for an in-form Irfan Pathan to be selected in the middle order instead of Kohli. This would reduce the pressure on the two frontline bowlers while giving a solid five man bowling attack. Irfan is not a bad middle order batsman - remember the 50 he scored as a opener in his man-of-the-match performance at the Perth Test in 2009?
If India fail to win their forst ever series in Australia against a fragile Australian team that has got out to 47 against SA and lost their first home test against NZ since 1986, Srikanth and Dhoni will need to take the blame.
According to me, the fitness of Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma and the frailty of the Australian batting order will determine the course of this match and the series. Sit back and relax and wait for the first ball to be bowled!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
The title would read "The late of two mis-selections". Lets start with Australia. The selection of Ricky Ponting and the omissions of Simon Katich and Usman Khwaja defy logic. Ricky Ponting is long past his due by date and should have gracefully retired. That the selectors led by Inverarity have lacked the courage to tap Ponting on his shoulder may come back to haunt the Aussies. He is a sitting duck and I for one won't be surprised if he his Ishant's bunny through this series! Usman Khwaja has shown great technique and deserved to be persisted with. If experience and form is a factor, Simon Katich (based on his average over the last 2 years) should have been an automatic selection! If Australia loses this game, Inverarity and his team have a lot to answer.
A look at the Indian bowling and one is surprised at the Indian selectors selecting a half fit Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma in the same team. Both have them have shown a penchant for falling apart during critical games. God forbid both of them break down during this critical Boxing Day test, and India will be left playing this game with no new ball bowlers. This will lead to Ponting and Hussey coming back to form! If India wanted to play both, it would have been logical for an in-form Irfan Pathan to be selected in the middle order instead of Kohli. This would reduce the pressure on the two frontline bowlers while giving a solid five man bowling attack. Irfan is not a bad middle order batsman - remember the 50 he scored as a opener in his man-of-the-match performance at the Perth Test in 2009?
If India fail to win their forst ever series in Australia against a fragile Australian team that has got out to 47 against SA and lost their first home test against NZ since 1986, Srikanth and Dhoni will need to take the blame.
According to me, the fitness of Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma and the frailty of the Australian batting order will determine the course of this match and the series. Sit back and relax and wait for the first ball to be bowled!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney
Saturday, April 2, 2011
The Virtual Stadium experience

Imagine being in a Stadium with all your classmates, child hood friends, neighbours, co-workers and relatives for the most important match of your life! Courtesy of Channel Nine, illegal video streaming and Facebook, I had the joy of seeing my dream come true last night and sharing the joy with all the people who matter to me in the World.
An avid Indian cricket fan living away from most of my friends in Sydney, Australia, I have been dreaming of the day when I watch India win the World Cup with all my friends. The GAME ran from 8PM to 4AM my time. Extremely tired after spending the day at an Amusement Park, I enjoyed the first innings with a friend over Black Label. Tired and sleepy, I was struggling to stay awake during the second innings. Thanks to the hundreds of updates, commments, likes, emotions portrayed by my friends over Facebook, I was able to stay awake and enjoy the WIN! We went through the tensions, agonies and joys together. Thanks a lot guys for the great time!
India has won the Cricket World Cup 2011!! I cannot describe my happiness.
Hopefully we will recreate the Virtual stadium at the end of the year when India is in Australia to try and overcome the final frontier i.e. win its first ever Test Series in Australia. Till next time..
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
Ricky Ponting
As the calls for Ricky Ponting’s head get louder, I would like to present my views on Ricky Ponting. Ricky Ponting is undoubtedly one of the best batsmen of our times. I have had the pleasure (Honestly speaking, as an Indian supporter, it wasn’t a pleasant experience at the time!) of watching him play at close quarters in 2003 and 2007 when India toured Australia. His records speak for themselves. He is Australia’s leading batsman in Tests and ODIs with more than 25,000 international runs at an average of 40-50. I distinctly remember his memorable knock of 96 on debut against Sri Lanka. Two innings that stand out in my mind are his performance against India in the 2003 World Cup (where he almost single handedly took the Cup away) and his innings of 240+ against India in the Melbourne Test of 2003! His captaincy record is extremely good and he is arguably one of Australia’s most successful captains.
Unfortunately, in my opinion, his sportsman spirit leaves a lot to be desired. He is a ruthless batsman and captain who plays to win at all costs! He does not believe in walking. I have no problem with this as it is an individual’s decision. But I have a problem with his philosophy that a batsman must take the word of a fielder for close catches! Remember the Sydney Test of 2008! Remember the times he has berated International players for not accepting the word of a fielder on a close catch. That, in my opinion, is hypocrisy. Is it easier for a batsman to know that he has nicked a ball or for a fielder to know that he has taken a catch cleanly when he is diving and rolling?
His on-field and off-field tantrums are far too many to be listed here. Ponting’s on-field dissent against on field umpires and opposing captains are legendary (Sydney Test 2008, Melbourne Test 2010 to quote a few). I read somewhere that Ponting has presided over more team offences during his captaincy reign than his predecessors Steve Waugh and Mark Taylor. Apparently, Ponting has been forced to pay more than $25,000 in fines since the behavioural measures were introduced in 1992. Of his eight breaches (an Australian record), five are related to umpire dissent.
It is looking likely that Australia will lose the upcoming Quarter Finals to India and Ponting dumped as the Captain of Australia. I think it is high time Ponting is sacked a Captain and is asked to continue as a specialist batsman.
I may be forced to eat my words in the event that Ponting scores a century and wins the game (and possibly the World Cup) for Australia and continues on!
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
Thursday, March 17, 2011
Cricket World Cup format
We are finally coming to an end of the Preliminary games of the World Cup! 6 long weeks and 45 games to eliminate 5 minnows and one of the 9 regular cricket playing teams.
This is an awful long time and far too many games to eliminate one of West Indies and Bangladesh, although England have threatened a number of times to get themselves eliminated and there is a remote chance India may be eliminated.
And then in 4 days and 4 games, 4 of the TOP 8 teams will be eliminated. This format provides no incentive to perform well in the Preliminary games. Once you “qualify” for the TOP 8, all teams are on even keel. The best team on the day will qualify for the Semi Final and the other team (even if they have won all their preliminary games) will be eliminated.
One can see the consumer disenchantment with this format with low ground attendance and low TRP ratings, notwithstanding the allegations of spot fixing and match fixing. We have also lost a number of big names to injury. Apparently, the long drawn out format is to appease the media and make the most of the media rights. I would argue that a crisp interesting format will lead to more spectators on the grounds and higher TRP ratings.
My format would be
1. Keep all the teams so we can still enjoy performances from Ireland(Kevin O'Brien), Netherlands (Ten Doeschate) and Canada (Patel) and the odd upset
2. Reduce the duration of the tournament by playing more games in parallel
3. TOP team in each group gets a direct entry to the Semi Finals
4. 2nd and 3rd team in each group play each other to determine the other semi finalists
I believe this will ensure that there is a lot of incentive for the teams during the preliminary games and also keep the consumer interest throughout the tournament by reducing the number of dead rubbers.
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
This is an awful long time and far too many games to eliminate one of West Indies and Bangladesh, although England have threatened a number of times to get themselves eliminated and there is a remote chance India may be eliminated.
And then in 4 days and 4 games, 4 of the TOP 8 teams will be eliminated. This format provides no incentive to perform well in the Preliminary games. Once you “qualify” for the TOP 8, all teams are on even keel. The best team on the day will qualify for the Semi Final and the other team (even if they have won all their preliminary games) will be eliminated.
One can see the consumer disenchantment with this format with low ground attendance and low TRP ratings, notwithstanding the allegations of spot fixing and match fixing. We have also lost a number of big names to injury. Apparently, the long drawn out format is to appease the media and make the most of the media rights. I would argue that a crisp interesting format will lead to more spectators on the grounds and higher TRP ratings.
My format would be
1. Keep all the teams so we can still enjoy performances from Ireland(Kevin O'Brien), Netherlands (Ten Doeschate) and Canada (Patel) and the odd upset
2. Reduce the duration of the tournament by playing more games in parallel
3. TOP team in each group gets a direct entry to the Semi Finals
4. 2nd and 3rd team in each group play each other to determine the other semi finalists
I believe this will ensure that there is a lot of incentive for the teams during the preliminary games and also keep the consumer interest throughout the tournament by reducing the number of dead rubbers.
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
Sunday, March 13, 2011
India’s loss to South Africa in the World Cup preliminary game
One may say it is just a game and someone has to win and someone has to lose. Why such a fuss! Agreed! I personally believe that there is a lot of fuss being made over the 45 preliminary games when in all probability the Top 8 teams will qualify for the Quarter Finals and once they reach the Quarters, none of the earlier results will matter.
Still, as someone who lost a significant portion of sleep over this game and as an avid cricket fan, I would like to analyse the game and present my views. Back to the original question - Why did India lose the game?
In my opinion, there are two possible reasons – one sinister and one cricketing! For the sake of this article I am going to assume that there is no match fixing or spot fixing during this World Cup and even if they did occur, they did not influence this game.
India got off to a flyer and was 120 odd for no loss at the end of 15 overs. My spontaneous reaction was India should take up the batting Power-Play immediately. This would have put the South Africans on the back foot and gotten us to say 160-170 in 20 overs just batting the way we were and effectively bat South Africa out of the game. I wasn’t expecting anyone to agree with me and was pleasantly surprised when Ravi Shastri echoed my views a couple of minutes later (I have witnesses to this)
India allowed South Africa to get back in the game with their spinners between the 16th and the 25th overs. But then Tendulkar and Gambhir played a massive role in almost taking the game away from South Africa by taking the score to 260 odd for 1 in 39 overs. Dhoni took the Batting Power-Play at this stage as expected. He then sent Yusuf Pathan ostensibly to up the ante. Once Yusuf got out, Dhoni did not back off and sent Yuvraj for possibly the same reason. Once India lost 4 wickets in succession, one would have expected Dhoni as the captain would take control of the situation. But as usual Dhoni pottered around at the crease scoring a strike rate of 50 and let everyone take a shot at scoring quickly and the rest as they say is history.
I for one went to bed at this stage (It was midnight my time) and did not follow the Indian bowling closely. But there are certain indisputable facts and questions to be asked? Nehra was playing a game after being out for injury. Why was Nehra given the ball for the last over? India’s most successful bowler of the day, Harbhajan Singh did not complete his quota of 10 overs. Why? Why was Harbhajan not given the last over? Why was Tendulkar or not given the last over? If anyone has forgotten, Tendulkar has helped India win in similar circumstances? Why is Sehwag never given a bowl these days? Who is the one person responsible for all these decisions?
It is easy to say that India lost because the middle order collapsed or maybe because Nehra bowled badly. That in my opinion is a cop out. In my opinion, based on the above facts, there is one individual who had control of the things that went wrong for India and who made wrong decisions at critical junctures of the game. Hence I believe that the reason for India’s loss is the poor captaincy of Mahendra Singh Dhoni. I rest my case.
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
Still, as someone who lost a significant portion of sleep over this game and as an avid cricket fan, I would like to analyse the game and present my views. Back to the original question - Why did India lose the game?
In my opinion, there are two possible reasons – one sinister and one cricketing! For the sake of this article I am going to assume that there is no match fixing or spot fixing during this World Cup and even if they did occur, they did not influence this game.
India got off to a flyer and was 120 odd for no loss at the end of 15 overs. My spontaneous reaction was India should take up the batting Power-Play immediately. This would have put the South Africans on the back foot and gotten us to say 160-170 in 20 overs just batting the way we were and effectively bat South Africa out of the game. I wasn’t expecting anyone to agree with me and was pleasantly surprised when Ravi Shastri echoed my views a couple of minutes later (I have witnesses to this)
India allowed South Africa to get back in the game with their spinners between the 16th and the 25th overs. But then Tendulkar and Gambhir played a massive role in almost taking the game away from South Africa by taking the score to 260 odd for 1 in 39 overs. Dhoni took the Batting Power-Play at this stage as expected. He then sent Yusuf Pathan ostensibly to up the ante. Once Yusuf got out, Dhoni did not back off and sent Yuvraj for possibly the same reason. Once India lost 4 wickets in succession, one would have expected Dhoni as the captain would take control of the situation. But as usual Dhoni pottered around at the crease scoring a strike rate of 50 and let everyone take a shot at scoring quickly and the rest as they say is history.
I for one went to bed at this stage (It was midnight my time) and did not follow the Indian bowling closely. But there are certain indisputable facts and questions to be asked? Nehra was playing a game after being out for injury. Why was Nehra given the ball for the last over? India’s most successful bowler of the day, Harbhajan Singh did not complete his quota of 10 overs. Why? Why was Harbhajan not given the last over? Why was Tendulkar or not given the last over? If anyone has forgotten, Tendulkar has helped India win in similar circumstances? Why is Sehwag never given a bowl these days? Who is the one person responsible for all these decisions?
It is easy to say that India lost because the middle order collapsed or maybe because Nehra bowled badly. That in my opinion is a cop out. In my opinion, based on the above facts, there is one individual who had control of the things that went wrong for India and who made wrong decisions at critical junctures of the game. Hence I believe that the reason for India’s loss is the poor captaincy of Mahendra Singh Dhoni. I rest my case.
Sai Mahesh
Sydney, Australia
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
