Where did India fall Short

With New Zealand coming off a series defeat to Sri Lanka, it was easy to assume they wouldn’t pose a serious challenge to India, especially in similar conditions. But one of India’s main adversaries turned out to be complacency itself—a mindset that often undercuts even the best teams.

Complacency and Selection Questions

The No. 4 batting spot is traditionally given to the most skilled batter, as it’s considered the ideal position to make an impact. However, despite nearly four years of underwhelming form, Virat Kohli’s place in this position has largely gone unchallenged due to his reputation.

Adding to this, Rohit Sharma’s recent statements about “big runs being overrated without tournament wins” may have hinted at a shift in focus, valuing impactful cameo contributions over sustained innings. While this approach may work in shorter formats, it doesn’t lend itself well to Test cricket, which could explain some inconsistency in his recent performances.

Skill Development and SENA-Focused Approach

Over the last decade, India’s strategy has heavily emphasized winning series in SENA (South Africa, England, New Zealand, and Australia) countries. To succeed in seaming conditions, Indian batsmen adapted their skills, often at the expense of their proficiency against spin—a traditional strength. The emphasis on international pitches has also limited the time players can spend in domestic circuits, which are critical for honing homegrown skills, especially against spin.

This oversight became evident in matches like Pune and Mumbai, where spin-friendly surfaces exposed the team’s weaknesses. Additionally, a rare failure on a seaming pitch, where India was bowled out for 46, indicated broader issues.

Mumbai Test Decisions

Heading into the Mumbai Test, it was known the pitch would be bone-dry, yet management chose to play with two seamers. This decision was puzzling, as only one seamer was likely needed on such a surface. Such tactical choices hinted at a lack of alignment between strategy and conditions, something even the average fan could question.

Looking Ahead

These points are only the most visible of India’s struggles. It’s time for a thorough introspection—identifying root causes, refining strategies, and making balanced, long-term decisions to strengthen the team’s overall health and resilience.